Birth Injury Medical Malpractice in Westchester County
There Is No Fee Unless We Secure Compensation
Trusted and Award-Winning Representation
Birth injuries can be devastating. When the result of malpractice, they are also unfair and can require extraordinary compensation so the injured child can obtain a decent quality of life going forward. Demands on parents and other caregivers can also be extraordinary. We have handled cases involving some of the most serious birth injuries, including cerebral palsy.
Cases in Westchester County present a distinct legal landscape. There are several hospitals providing maternity services, each with their own organization, professional affiliations, and protocols. Each also carries different legal frameworks that affect how, and when, a suit may be brought.
Of note, Westchester Medical Center (WMC) is involved in almost 2,000 obstetrical deliveries a year. It also operates a Level IV Regional Neonatal Intensive Care Unit (NICU) and is a destination hospital for some of the sickest neonates. However, its legal status as a state-affiliated public benefit corporation can create legal pitfalls if suit is attempted by a law firm without sufficient experience in the medical malpractice legal landscape. Under this designation, a plaintiff must first file a Notice of Claim within 90 days of the malpractice before bringing suit. The lawsuit filing itself has a shortened deadline of 1 year and 90 days, as opposed to the standard 2.5-year time limit applicable to private hospitals. This shortest period applies to parental claims and should be used for conservative planning purposes. Claims for the infant on their own behalf may be extended, or tolled, for infancy, for a maximum of 10 years.
Other obstetrical hospitals in Westchester, including White Plains Hospital, NewYork-Presbyterian/Lawrence Hospital, Montefiore New Rochelle, Northern Westchester Hospital, and Phelps Hospital, are private. These have the standard 2.5-year deadline for parental claims.
We have represented families in birth injury cases against major hospitals and health networks, including in Westchester County. We understand the organization and policies of these hospitals and are used to litigating against the law firms that defend them. We understand the relevant medicine, the law of malpractice, and the local procedural requirements.
Key Takeaways
- Deadline splits by hospital type: Westchester Medical Center (WMC) requires a Notice of Claim within 90 days; private hospitals allow 2.5 years under New York’s Civil Practice Law and Rules (CPLR) § 214-a for the parent’s claims.
- Child’s case may have extended time: Under CPLR § 208(a), there is an extension, or toll, for the child’s claims, which runs up to 10 years from the act of malpractice itself.
- Fetal monitoring can be central evidence: The American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists (ACOG) Practice Bulletin No. 106 (2009; based on the 2008 NICHD Workshop) establishes fetal monitoring categories that can be key evidence in whether labor and delivery was properly handled.
- Hospital parent corporations matter: White Plains Hospital is part of Montefiore Health System; Phelps and Northern Westchester are Northwell Health affiliates. Our understanding of these affiliations, and the policies and protocols of the parent healthcare networks, can also be key evidence in the case.
- Past results: We have obtained multi-million dollar compensation in birth injury cases, including in Westchester County. Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome; case results vary by facts and circumstances.
Under New York law, medical malpractice is defined as a “deviation” or “departure” from accepted standards of medical practice that proximately causes injury (NY Pattern Jury Instruction 2:150). In birth injury cases, many standards are adopted from the American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists (ACOG) — its Practice Bulletins and Clinical Practice Guidelines set the benchmarks against which much obstetric care is measured. What a Westchester hospital’s obstetric team did, or did not do, and when, is compared to ACOG guidelines and analyzed by our team of OB-GYN experts.
Filing Deadlines: Why Westchester Medical Center Is Different
The single most important threshold question in any Westchester birth injury case is whether the delivery took place at Westchester Medical Center or one of the county’s private hospitals. The answer controls your deadline — and missing it bars the case entirely.
| Hospital | Classification | Notice of Claim Deadline | Lawsuit Deadline |
|---|---|---|---|
| Westchester Medical Center | Public benefit corporation (WCHCC) | 90 days from the incident | 1 year and 90 days (GML § 50-i) for parental claims; infant’s claim may be extended |
| White Plains Hospital (Montefiore) | Private | Not required | 2.5 years (CPLR § 214-a) for parental claims; infant’s own claims may be up to 10 years |
| NewYork-Presbyterian/Lawrence | Private | Not required | 2.5 years (CPLR § 214-a) for parental claims; infant’s own claims may be up to 10 years |
| Montefiore New Rochelle | Private | Not required | 2.5 years (CPLR § 214-a) for parental claims; infant’s own claims may be up to 10 years |
| Northern Westchester Hospital (Northwell Health) | Private (Northwell Health network) | Not required | 2.5 years (CPLR § 214-a) for parental claims; infant’s own claims may be up to 10 years |
| Phelps Hospital (Northwell Health) | Private (Northwell Health network) | Not required | 2.5 years (CPLR § 214-a) for parental claims; infant’s own claims may be up to 10 years |
Westchester Medical Center is operated by Westchester County Health Care Corporation (WCHCC), a New York State public benefit corporation. WCHCC’s enabling statute (NY Public Authorities Law §§ 2820–2826, including PAL § 3316) incorporates the General Municipal Law (GML) § 50-e Notice-of-Claim procedure and the GML § 50-i 1-year-and-90-day statute of limitations by reference. The practical result: claims against WMC require service of a Notice of Claim within 90 days of the incident, and the underlying lawsuit must be commenced within 1 year and 90 days — not the standard 2.5 years under CPLR § 214-a that applies to private hospitals.
The 90-day deadline at Westchester Medical Center does not pause while you wait for a diagnosis, gather records, or find an attorney. It runs from the date of the incident. If your child was born at WMC and something went wrong during delivery, contact us immediately — we determine your exact deadline before we do anything else.
The Infancy Toll — What It Actually Provides for Birth Injury Cases
A common misunderstanding is that a child’s “infancy toll” under CPLR § 208(a) provides unlimited additional time until the child reaches adulthood — giving the family into the child’s twenties to file. That rule applies to some types of personal injury cases but does not apply to medical malpractice claims.
In medical malpractice, CPLR § 208(a) caps the infancy toll at ten years from the act or omission. A child born in Westchester County who suffered a preventable birth injury — regardless of when that injury is diagnosed — has until ten years after the date of birth to commence a malpractice action on the child’s own behalf. After that cap, the statute runs.
Parents’ own claims, including claims for expenses they have incurred and will incur, and for their own distress, get no time extension for the infancy toll. Parent claims are governed by the standard deadline applicable to the hospital where delivery occurred — the 90-day Notice of Claim deadline for WMC and 2.5 years for private hospitals.
As a practical matter, evaluation must take place well before expiration of any deadline. Records take time to obtain. Expert review by board-certified obstetricians and maternal-fetal medicine specialists takes time. The investigation needs to be complete before we can assess whether a case exists and begin the filing process.
What Constitutes Malpractice in an OB Case — The PJI 2:150 Standard
New York Pattern Jury Instruction 2:150 defines medical malpractice as a departure from accepted standards of medical practice, or failure to provide reasonable care, that is a proximate cause of injury. In obstetric cases, many accepted standards are defined by ACOG guidelines, although in some instances an OB expert may apply more general standards of what was, or was not, reasonable.
To establish a successful case, two elements must be present: (a) the obstetric team departed from the standard of care or reasonable care, AND (b) that departure was a substantial factor in causing the child’s injury, which is legal proximate cause. We obtain all needed expert testimony, including board-certified obstetricians, maternal-fetal medicine specialists, and pediatric neurologists, to address both components of the case.
Common Birth Injury Failures in Westchester Hospital OB Units
Failure to Respond to Ominous Fetal Heart Rate Patterns
There are recognized patterns of ominous fetal heart readings that should prompt action. Many cases are based on failure to properly appreciate and react to fetal monitoring findings.
ACOG Practice Bulletin No. 106 (2009; based on the 2008 NICHD Workshop) classifies intrapartum fetal heart rate (FHR) tracings as Category I (normal), Category II (indeterminate), or Category III (abnormal — indicating probable fetal acidemia). A Category III tracing, by ACOG guidelines, requires prompt evaluation and expedited delivery. Category II tracings with worsening features require escalating response, including repositioning, oxygen, IV fluids, and preparation for cesarean if the pattern does not resolve.
Fetal monitoring should be maintained as a continuous written record. The time each pattern appeared, and when nursing and the obstetrician responded, is documented in the chart. When a Category III pattern sat unaddressed for a prolonged period while a baby was distressed in utero, the monitoring record itself may provide powerful evidence.
Delayed Cesarean Section
In true obstetric emergencies, including Category III patterns, cord prolapse, and placental abruption, the ACOG/AAP Guidelines for Perinatal Care identify 30 minutes as an institutional readiness benchmark for emergent cesarean delivery. In practice, many experts believe ACOG deliberately set that bar conservatively. If a team for a crash C-section is available, and the infant is truly in dire distress, it can still be malpractice if the team is not able to effectuate delivery in well under that time.
We obtain operating room (OR) logs, anesthesia records, and time-stamped nursing notes to reconstruct exactly how long elapsed between the decision for cesarean and delivery, or whether the decision itself was unduly delayed.
A related category of case results when the on-call obstetrician decides not to promptly evaluate, after a nurse or other provider calls about concerning findings.
Shoulder Dystocia and Erb’s Palsy
Shoulder dystocia occurs when the fetal shoulder becomes impacted behind the maternal pubic bone after the head delivers. This is an obstetric emergency requiring immediate and specific maneuvers. ACOG Practice Bulletin No. 178 (Shoulder Dystocia) identifies maneuvers that should be attempted to relieve shoulder dystocia. Cases may be based on failure to use the correct maneuvers, or applying excessive traction, which may cause lifelong injuries to the brachial plexus and produce Erb’s palsy.
We obtain the delivery note and examine exactly what maneuvers were documented. Often, depositions of the involved providers provide critical evidence on what was really done, even if the notes say everything was done correctly.
Hypoxic-Ischemic Encephalopathy (HIE)
HIE — hypoxic-ischemic encephalopathy — is a clinical syndrome of neonatal brain damage caused by an in utero event that impairs blood supply to the fetal brain during labor and delivery. HIE is sometimes caused by preventable delay in delivery. When that is the case, this may be a viable birth injury claim. We review the fetal monitoring records, NICU records, placental pathology, and MRI brain imaging to help us and our experts determine the timing of the hypoxic event, including whether it occurred during a period when obstetric intervention was required but not taken.
American Academy of Pediatrics / American Heart Association (AAP/AHA) Neonatal Resuscitation Program (NRP) protocols provide guidelines for resuscitation at delivery. When a baby arrives depressed — poor tone, absent respiratory effort, low Apgar scores — NRP specifies the required steps and timing. Failure to follow NRP algorithms to resuscitate a partially compromised infant, making the problem worse, is also a recognized basis for a malpractice claim.
High-Risk Pregnancy Mismanagement
Obstetricians have a duty to identify high-risk pregnancies and provide specialized attention.
Relevant standards are set forth in ACOG Practice Bulletin No. 229, addressing fetal surveillance for high-risk conditions such as gestational diabetes, preeclampsia, intrauterine growth restriction, or post-term pregnancy beyond 41 weeks. High risk can also be created by multiple gestations and prior cesarean delivery.
These high-risk conditions require heightened monitoring and, in some cases, referral to Maternal Fetal Medicine, or high-risk pregnancy, providers. The risk status also affects how long a mother can safely labor before cesarean section. If a Westchester County OB team fails to recognize warning signs in a high-risk pregnancy, or delays recommended intervention, and the baby is permanently injured, that failure may be the foundation of a malpractice claim.
Transfer Failures from Community Hospitals
Not every area hospital has the same NICU capabilities. Westchester Medical Center operates the county’s Level IV Regional NICU, capable of handling the most critically ill neonates. When a baby in distress is delivered at a hospital without equivalent neonatal support and a STAT transfer to WMC is delayed, that delay may itself constitute malpractice by the transferring facility. In addition to the medical records, we examine inter-facility transfer protocols, transport logs, and evidence of communications between the relevant institutions.
How We Investigate Birth Injuries in Westchester County
We obtain and analyze several types of evidence to evaluate a potential birth injury case, beginning with the complete obstetric record.
Records we obtain: Complete prenatal records from all treating providers; labor and delivery records; continuous fetal heart rate monitoring strips; nursing notes with time-stamps; obstetrician delivery notes; anesthesia records; OR logs for cesarean deliveries; newborn records; NICU records from WMC or the admitting facility; placental pathology reports; MRI and neuroimaging; and the hospital’s own written obstetric protocols governing fetal monitoring response, emergency cesarean decision-to-incision timing, and shoulder dystocia management.
We also interview the patient and family members to obtain their first-hand recollection of what happened, and when. This is often critical to fill in gaps in the records. When did you tell the nurse you were concerned? How long before the doctor appeared? What did they tell you? What were your symptoms? What the chart does not say can be as important as what it does.
To evaluate matters, and during litigation, we send records to board-certified obstetricians and other relevant experts, such as maternal-fetal medicine specialists, to assess whether departures from accepted standards occurred and what the standards required at each point in the timeline. We work with pediatric neurologists who determine the timing and cause of brain injury from the clinical records, NICU course, and neuroimaging. Some questions we ask: Did the monitoring show a pattern that required intervention? When should the obstetrician have been called? When should the decision for delivery have been made? Would earlier delivery likely have prevented the injury?
Westchester County Hospitals — What We Know About Each
| Hospital | Parent Network | Key Notes for Birth Injury Cases |
|---|---|---|
| Westchester Medical Center | Westchester County Health Care Corporation (public benefit corp) | Level IV Regional NICU; 90-day Notice of Claim required; 1-year-90-day statute of limitations (GML § 50-i); we have litigated against WMC and its defense counsel |
| White Plains Hospital | Montefiore Health System | Private; member of Montefiore Health System — corporate structure should be evaluated to determine whether Montefiore Medical Center or its parent should also be named; NICU capabilities; 2.5-year SOL |
| NewYork-Presbyterian/Lawrence | NewYork-Presbyterian system | Private; part of NYP academic network; resident and fellow involvement in labor and delivery is a recognized failure mode at teaching-affiliated hospitals |
| Montefiore New Rochelle | Montefiore Health System | Private; Montefiore network — multi-facility coordination between this campus and the main Montefiore system is a potential failure point |
| Northern Westchester Hospital | Northwell Health | Private; Northwell network affiliate; 2.5-year SOL |
| Phelps Hospital | Northwell Health | Private; Northwell network affiliate; 2.5-year SOL |
As noted above, Westchester Medical Center — as a state-affiliated public benefit corporation — requires a 90-day Notice of Claim and carries a 1-year-90-day statute of limitations under GML § 50-e and § 50-i, not the standard 2.5-year SOL applicable to the five private hospitals listed. Northern Westchester Hospital and Phelps Hospital are both Northwell Health affiliates. In cases against either facility, the relationship between the local hospital and Northwell Health Inc. should be evaluated to determine whether the parent or related entities should also be named, depending on staffing, billing, and corporate-control facts.
Our Experience
We have deep experience with the medical issues and law of birth injury malpractice, and developed relationships with leading experts in obstetrics, pediatrics, and related fields. We also have direct successful experience in cases against Westchester institutions and the attorneys who represent them.
We have also litigated successfully against the parent networks with which many Westchester hospitals are affiliated: Montefiore, Northwell, and NewYork-Presbyterian. We know how these firms conduct litigation, and understand how these cases are defended in Westchester County Supreme Court.
At hospitals affiliated with residency programs, such as NewYork-Presbyterian and Montefiore-affiliated facilities, a recurring failure mode is excessive delegation to residents or fellows. A prominent but too-busy specialist who delegates too much to an inexperienced resident can be a recipe for disaster during a complicated labor. We are sensitive to these issues and seek to uncover them in the course of litigation.
Compensation in Westchester Birth Injury Cases
Permanent birth injuries in Westchester County impose lifelong costs. As of 2026, courts have awarded substantial damages in NY birth injury malpractice cases — reflecting the real, lifetime economic burden these injuries impose. We quantify damages through retained third-party experts.
We retain Life Care Planners who project the child’s lifetime medical and rehabilitation costs — all hospitalizations, surgeries, medications, physical therapy, occupational therapy, speech therapy, adaptive equipment, and specialized medical care from infancy through adulthood. We retain vocational experts who calculate lost earning capacity if the injury prevents working. We retain economists who compute present-value damages.
Damage to the brain is not like any other injury. Cerebral palsy and severe HIE impose lifelong functional limitations. Children with these conditions do not just suffer a loss of function — they typically experience profound emotional effects and loss of the full range of what their lives might have been. We seek full and fair compensation to secure maximum assistance for their therapy, independence, and dignity.
New York does not cap non-economic damages in medical malpractice cases. There is no statutory limit on compensation for the child’s conscious pain and suffering — their awareness of their condition and their inability to participate in activities other children can enjoy. Even for individuals who are not gainfully employed, the loss of ability to engage in activities may be sufficient, and significant damages are available.
Parent claims run alongside the child’s claim: parents may recover for their own expenses, past and future, and for the emotional distress of witnessing their child’s injury and providing care. Parent claims are separate from — and do not reduce — the child’s damages.
We have obtained multi-million dollar results in birth injury cases that reflect the severity of these injuries, including cases in Westchester County. Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome; case results vary by facts and circumstances.
Questions to Consider About Your Westchester Birth Injury Case
When evaluating whether you believe you experienced substandard care at a Westchester hospital, consider:
- Did the fetal monitoring show signs of distress that nursing noted but the obstetrician did not promptly address?
- Was there a prolonged delay between the decision for cesarean section and the time your baby was delivered?
- Did shoulder dystocia occur?
- Was your pregnancy classified as high-risk?
- Do you feel that there was an unreasonable delay at any point — in calling the doctor, deciding on cesarean, or transferring the baby to the NICU?
- Did any of the doctors or nurses in the hospital tell you that you should “see a lawyer”?
These subjective impressions often identify cases worth investigating. When providers themselves suggest legal consultation, it frequently indicates that someone in the room recognized a departure from the standard of care.
Where Westchester Birth Injury Cases Are Filed
Cases against Westchester County hospitals are filed in Supreme Court, Westchester County, located at 111 Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. Blvd, White Plains, NY 10601. We have offices in Westchester (1 Chase Road, Scarsdale) as well as Midtown Manhattan to best serve our clients where they work and live.
Frequently Asked Questions: Birth Injuries at Westchester County Hospitals
What is the deadline to file a birth injury case if my child was born at Westchester Medical Center?
Westchester Medical Center is a public benefit corporation. Claims against WMC require a Notice of Claim served within 90 days of the incident under NY General Municipal Law § 50-e, and the lawsuit must be commenced within 1 year and 90 days under GML § 50-i. This is dramatically shorter than the 2.5-year deadline that applies to private hospitals. Missing the 90-day deadline typically bars the case entirely, regardless of how serious the injury. Contact us immediately if your child was born at WMC and something went wrong.
Does my child get extra time to file because they were an infant when the injury occurred?
Under CPLR § 208, the infancy toll for medical malpractice claims is capped at ten years from the act or omission — not until age 18 plus 2.5 years. A child injured at birth has until ten years from the birth date to commence a malpractice action on the child’s own behalf. Parent claims are not tolled — parent deadlines run from the date of the incident. For WMC births, the parent Notice of Claim deadline of 90 days is not extended by the child’s infancy. As a practical matter, we recommend contacting us as early as possible, not at year nine.
How do you prove the hospital caused my child’s cerebral palsy?
We obtain the fetal monitoring records, delivery records, and NICU records. If our review indicates a likely basis for a case, we send these materials to experts, such as maternal-fetal medicine specialists, who help us identify whether concerning patterns were ignored or mismanaged. We retain pediatric neurologists who help us determine when the hypoxic injury occurred.
My child has developmental delays but no formal cerebral palsy diagnosis yet. Can I still file a case?
It is possible. Many birth injuries are not formally diagnosed until 12 to 24 months, when motor or cognitive delays become evident. However, the filing deadline still runs from the date of birth — not from diagnosis. A child born at WMC still has only 90 days for the Notice of Claim to be served. Do not wait for a formal diagnosis before consulting with us. We can investigate from the records regardless of whether a diagnosis has been assigned.
My child had Erb’s palsy after shoulder dystocia. Is that automatically malpractice?
No. Shoulder dystocia can sometimes occur even with proper management. We retain obstetricians who review the delivery record and render an opinion on whether care met the standard.
What compensation is available for permanent birth injuries in New York?
New York does not cap non-economic damages in medical malpractice cases. For permanent injuries, compensation includes lifetime medical care costs calculated by a Life Care Planner, lost earning capacity calculated by vocational experts and economists, the child’s conscious pain and suffering, and parent claims for their own expenses and emotional distress. Even for children who may never work, the loss of independence and ability to engage in normal activities supports significant damages. We retain the experts needed to calculate and document every element.
Speak With a Westchester Birth Injury Attorney
If your child suffered a birth injury at a Westchester County hospital, and you have serious questions about whether care was properly managed, we would be happy to speak with you. Please contact us for a no-cost case evaluation.